Vol. 1 No. 49 (2025): COMMENTS ON THE MAIN RULINGS OF THE SUPREME FEDERAL COURT

View Vol. 1 No. 49 (2025): COMMENTS ON THE MAIN RULINGS OF THE SUPREME FEDERAL COURT

The 49th edition of the ESASP Journal - Virtual Scientific Journal of the Escola Superior de Advocacia of OAB/SP presents a systematic analysis of the main rulings issued by the Supreme Federal Court during the year 2025. The thirty-two articles compiled here offer a comprehensive overview of constitutional jurisdictional activity, addressing topics ranging from specific procedural issues to major substantive law controversies with significant social impact. The set of commented decisions reveals the thematic diversity that characterizes contemporary constitutional jurisdiction.

Published: 2025-11-05

Editorial

Preface

Erik Chiconelli Gomes (Author)

8-9
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
Constitutional Challenges and the Supreme Court: Presentation of the STF Case Law Dossier

Fabio Paulo Reis de Santana (Author)

9-10
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))

Articles

ARE 1,042,275/RJ (Theme 977 GA) Police access to data from cell phones found at crime scenes

Maurício Schaun Jalil (Author)

11-13
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 970,343/PR (Theme 111 GA) Unconstitutionality of offsetting court-ordered debts (EC 30/00)

Raphael Molina, Guilherme Molina, Juliana Rímoli Molina (Author)

14-16
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ARE 1,553,243/CE (Theme 1,420 GA) Control judicial en comisiones de heteroidentificación

Simone Henrique (Author)

17-18
ARE 1,539,801/SP Procedural aspects of the Extraordinary Appeal

Augusto César Monteiro Filho (Author)

19-20
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADIs 7,600, 7,601, and 7,608 Constitutionality of extrajudicial execution of collateral

Reinaldo Roberto Ghesso (Author)

21-24
RE 1,326,178/SC (Theme 1,156 GA) Payment of super-preferential court orders and small value requisitions (RPV)

Eurico Souza Leite Filho (Author)

25-26
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 5,644 Autonomy of the Public Defender's Office and management of the Assistance Fund

Luiz Rascovski (Author)

27-28
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 631,363/SP (Theme 284 GA) and RE 632,212/SP (Theme 285 GA) Economic Plans and savings account correction

Alex Faria Pereira (Author)

29-30
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 2,965 State competence in the oversight of private education

Márcia Walquiria Batista dos Santos, João Eduardo Lopes Queiroz (Author)

31-33
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7,231 Defense of legal profession prerogatives against legislative error

Marcello Antonio Fiore (Author)

34-35
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7,021 Party Federations and the isonomy of electoral deadlines

Juliana Cardoso Ribeiro Bastos, Luiz Gustavo Andrade (Author)

36-38
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7,553 Constitutionality of the increase in state court fees

Fábio Franco Pereira (Author)

39-40
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7,719 Inconstitucionalidad de la obligatoriedad de bolsas plásticas gratuitas

Carlos Eduardo Fernandes da Silveira, Carlos Ogawa Colontonio (Author)

41-44
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 1.490.708/SP (Theme 1.367 RG) ICMS on the transfer of goods between states

Eduardo Figueiras Ismael, Julia Moura de Souza (Author)

45-47
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 5.043 The exclusivity of criminal investigation by the Chief of Police

Guilherme Lobo Marchioni (Author)

48-50
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 1.426.083 (Theme 1.277 RG) Territorial jurisdiction and Special Federal Courts

Carlos Ogawa Colontonio (Author)

51-53
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
MI 7.452 Legislative delay in protection against domestic violence (LGBTQIA+)

Marcelo Brito Guimarães (Author)

54-56
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7.873 The new court-ordered debt regime and Constitutional Amendment 136/2025

Jucilene de Campos dos Santos (Author)

57-61
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7.715 Illegal occupants, invaders of rural and urban private properties, and the application of sanctions at the state level

Diogenes Nielsen Júnior (Author)

62-63
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 5.728 Vaquejada practice as a cultural manifestation and the constitutionality of EC 96/2017

Josafá Marques da Silva Ramos (Author)

64-66
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 1,326,559/SC (Theme 1,220 RG) The constitutionality of the preference of legal fees over tax credits

Tiago Romano (Author)

67-69
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 6.085 Legislative process, substitute amendment, and the requirement of return to the initiating House

Ricardo Teixeira da Silva, Tassiane de Fátima Moraes (Author)

70-72
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADPF 1.066 The unconstitutionality of municipal exemption from legal fees in the Special Tax Regularization Program (PERT)

José Luiz Souza de Moraes (Author)

73-76
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7.727 The Social Security Reform and the retirement of female police officers from the perspective of substantive equality

Liliane Aparecida Ferreira Fonseca (Author)

77-79
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADO 62 Unconstitutional omission in the regulation of assistance to heirs of victims of intentional crimes

Mirian Gomes, Maria Fernanda Gomes Azambuja (Author)

80-82
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADO 85 Legislative delay in the regulation of worker participation in company management

Renato Cassio Soares de Barros (Author)

83-85
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 5.761 Regulation of the civil firefighter profession and the limits of state legislative competence

Marco Antonio Hatem Beneton (Author)

86-87
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 1.037.396/SP (Theme 987) e RE 1.057.258/ MG(Theme 533) The liability of digital platforms for third-party content and the constitutionality of art. 19 of the Civil Framework for the Internet

Marcelo Fonseca Santos (Author)

88-90
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
RE 1,298,647 (Theme 1,118 RG) Burden of proof and the subsidiary liability of the Public Administration in outsourcing

Felipe Gonçalves Fernandes (Author)

91-97
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7.641 Financial autonomy of the Judiciary and the limits of the expenditure ceiling on own revenues

Vanessa Cerqueira Reis de Carvalho (Author)

98-99
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADPF 982 Competence of Courts of Auditors to judge management accounts of mayors acting as expenditure originators

Eduardo Leandro de Queiroz e Souza, Graziela Nóbrega da Silva, Tatiana Barone Sussa (Author)

100-102
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))
ADI 7.746 Remuneration linking and the limits of equalization between public employees and permanent civil servants

José Jerônimo Nogueira de Lima (Author)

103-106
- pdf (Portuguese (Brazil))